Trouble at OverTrails Farm: A Journey of Challenge, Persistence, and Awareness
About
Literary Titan Silver Medal Book Award 2026
Small farm, big heart--and a cover-up that leaves a gentle soul to take the fall
OverTrails Farm is meant to be a place of healing. The therapeutic riding stable in rural central Virginia offers confidence, connection, and calm—until the sudden death of a young employee shatters its sense of safety.
When suspicion falls on a disabled volunteer and former student of the program, a close-knit group of teens who ride and volunteer at the farm are unwilling to accept this theory.
Determined to uncover the truth, they begin their own quiet investigation. As they piece together overlooked details, they confront family tensions, unspoken fears, and the subtle ways bias shapes how others see—and misjudge—those who are different.
Their search tests their courage, their loyalty, and their willingness to examine their own assumptions. In challenging the easy story everyone is ready to believe, they help their community move toward a new understanding of responsibility, fairness, and the dignity of every person.
Set against the charm of small-town Virginia, the healing world of therapeutic riding, and the bond between humans and horses, Trouble at OverTrails Farm is a clean cozy mystery filled with heart, hope, and the enduring power of friendship. It is a story about seeing beyond labels, fighting for those who can’t fight alone, and discovering the strength of community when it matters most. This is a story for readers who believe kindness and truth still matter.
Praise for this book
..."I liked how the book makes friendship its real engine. The mystery matters, but Nina’s fierce defense of Alex gives the story its pulse. Her anger is not reckless melodrama; it comes from moral clarity. She sees how quickly a vulnerable person can be misread, patronized, or used as a convenient answer, and she refuses to let that calcify into “truth.” That emotional through-line gives the investigation more weight than a simple whodunit.
The farm setting also works beautifully. Horses, trails, barns, tack rooms, and the rhythms of therapeutic riding create a textured, quietly absorbing world. At times, the prose explains more than it needs to, but the book’s sincerity really draws you in. I was especially drawn to the way Lewis treats disability, anxiety, and self-worth not as decorative “issues,” but as authentic realities that shape how characters move through danger, friendship, and trust.
The target audience for this cozy mystery and friendship adventure includes readers who like suspense with a strong ethical center. Readers who enjoy Nancy Drew-style sleuthing but want a gentler, more socially conscious contemporary story will feel at home here. Trouble at OverTrails Farm is a warm-hearted mystery with a bridle in one hand and a moral compass in the other."